Star Wars: The Last Jedi in-depth fan review: ‘From being underwhelmed to truly embracing a film with heart.’

SPOILER WARNING: There is a general discussion of the film’s content in the following review.

Sometimes I wish the original trilogy were the only films ever made. They were perfect in my eyes. But I am happy to admit I have embraced the whole Star Wars saga (which includes six seasons of the TV series The Clone Wars and Rebels, currently into its fourth season) over a lifetime, despite some of my reservations that the prequels were somewhat of an exercise in indulgence by George Lucas. That said, some of it was awful and some of it was really good, especially The Revenge of the Sith (2005).

More recently a wonderful reboot under the control of the Disney empire without uncle George has seen the franchise slowly grapple with expectations of hard die fans and moving the saga forward. A few years ago I said that handing over the reins of the Star Wars franchise was probably the best thing for its continued future and success. It was also quite understandable at the time how uncle George feared that his vision of Star Wars might be totally compromised with a new trilogy ‘storyboarded’ by a new generation. I like to think that this current trilogy with The Force Awakens as its anchor, and the Star Wars reboot in general with Rogue One, a stand-alone film and another few more still forthcoming, is pretty much in safe hands. If you can only see me sitting here writing that last sentence, I really had to pinch myself to see that I was awake. Believe me I am fully aware of the hate campaign against Kennedy & Co. and the growing reaction from hardcore fans that Disney is trying to kill Star Wars. 

Two weekends ago, I saw the latest instalment in the Skywalker saga, Star Wars: The Last Jedi. But before I give you my two cents worth, its important to mention that the lead up and secrecy around the film, and the plot theories and conspiracies surrounding Rey, Luke and even Mark Hamill’s reluctance about what should happen to Luke, was beyond anything I had imagined. Importantly, we also heard that The Last Jedi director, Rian Johnson, was given a green light by Disney to write and direct a new Star Wars trilogy. Instantly rumours buzzed around that, for Johnson to be given a blank canvas on three new Star Wars movies, The Last Jedi must be masterpiece, right? I knew that it was dangerous to believe that a film could be great without even seeing it, but nonetheless my expectations now were through the roof! I had even resigned myself to reluctantly accept whatever fate awaited Rey, Luke and even Leia, knowing Carrie Fisher will never return the big screen again with her sad passing last year. And so as the lights dimmed in the theatre, I held my breath and hoped for the best. 

The first part of The Last Jedi sees our heroes, the Resistance, led by Leia Organa, trying to evacuate from their base on D’Qar, which is under attack from the menacing First Order. A very costly space battle takes place above the planet led by Poe Dameron, which almost completely decimates the capabilities of the Resistance. They escape by jumping into hyperspace, but a short time after it is revealed that they have been tracked all along through hyperspace by the First Order, when they re-emerge in real time space, and there is no hope of escape. (More recently this astonishing revelation was brought to my attention by several friends, who noticed that the hyperspace tracking project was mentioned in Rogue One by Jyn Erso, when she was scanning the Empire’s database to find the Death Star plans. How did I miss that? And how’s that for a cool Easter egg!)

Across the galaxy at the site of the First Jedi Temple, Rey finds herself in the presence of a legend, Luke Skywalker, a Jedi master unwilling to help her or the fledgling Resistance led by his sister Leia, to fight against the First Order, who is hell-bent on crushing them. While Skywalker makes it very clear to Rey that he came to Ahch-To to die, Rey has many questions she wants answered, especially her place in the galaxy. But it isn’t long before Luke realises that Rey has a connection to the dark side and to his nephew Ben Solo, aka Kylo Ren, which is something that truly frightens him.

By the end of the two and half hour film, it was hard not to walk out of the theatre feeling emotional, confused and especially relieved that Rey, whom I adore as the latest Star Wars female heroine, remains somewhat unscathed after her misadventure on Ahch-To and her later ordeal under Snoke. (My greatest fear was that she would turn to the dark side.) But as the faces of people whom had shared the same experience, smiled and beamed with excitement, I was torn by my initial overall expectations. I was somewhat underwhelmed by the film and my feelings for it, and yet this was still despite the very positive reviews I read later that night at home. I’ll see how I feel about it in a few more days I thought and upon seeing it again.

The Last Jedi did its best to try and piss me off straight after the opening crawl, with Poe’s stand up comedy routine, heckling First Order’s General Hux. It wasn’t long after that I wondered whether I had come to see a comedy or a space opera, especially when Luke unceremoniously throws his lightsaber over his shoulder. It received lots of laughs in the cinema, which I believe should have been a more serious moment, leading us to eventually understand why Luke had rejected his Jedi life. Don’t get me wrong, humour definitely has its place in Star Wars, but there was an overemphasis of it in this film. It is at times cheap and cheesy, but for the most part I guess it works?

Other things troubled me too, some flaws and things that I could have done without, such as Maz Kanata’s cameo and the surprisingly annoying General Hux, bobbing up strategically at plot points trying to look important. Is it just me or were there too many new aliens and creatures? It was like Rian was showboating. Dude, you can expand the Star Wars universe with subtlety, I don’t need to see that there are hundreds of new star systems and live forms, sometimes it is nice to imagine it. The reliance of CGI, definitely one of the sins of the prequels, is also heavy-handed under the watch of Rian Johnson, but it admittedly does serve its purpose, in the best of the action sequences and explosive battle scenes. We seriously could have also done without the pointless extravagant Canto Bight/ casino side story in which Finn and new Star Wars character Rose Tico, attempt to find a master code breaker, so that they can sneak on board Snoke’s flagship and disable the hyperspace tracker, allowing what remains of The Resistance to escape. And while on the subject of Finn, he is wasted in a lackluster performance by John Boyega. Though his only saving grace might be his attempted kamikaze attack on the First Order’s laser battering ram canon in the film’s finale.

Screen Shot 2017-12-25 at 11.31.33 PM.png

There are, of course, a litter of other smaller flaws, but they are just simply not worth getting into here, without sounding really petty. Ok, maybe just one more. I really hated that grossed out milking alien cows thing with Luke. What up with that? But the fact that I had noticed so many things that initially bothered me, probably suggests that The Last Jedi wasn’t working for me, right? Star Wars will always be divisive and we are always going to pick out the things we love and hate about it. The Last Jedi is by no means a weak film, it is unprecedented in scope for trying to be different or is difficult a better word to describe Johnson’s new Star Wars film?  One of the more thoughtful emotionally-charged critiques of The Last Jedi was written by my friend Master Awan. He loves Star Wars as much as I do, if not more, but I think we may have to agree to disagree on some of what he has said in his provisional review.

Since then I have now seen it twice and have to some degree moved on from my initial disappointment. I don’t know what bothered me the most about it last week. The fact that it was promised that Rian Johnson would deliver an epic film that would rival The Empire Strikes Back or that the ending, including Luke’s choice to die, was something that I really deep down wasn’t prepared for. I also initially found myself questioning the originality of The Last Jedi, which I had dearly hoped for, but in some sense Johnson hadn’t moved it enough away from being a Skywalker saga? 

You may get the impression that I seem keen on moving away from the original trilogy as a fan, truly ready to embrace the next chapter of the Star Wars story. That is to some extent correct. I mentioned earlier above that the original trilogy was in my eyes perfect and that many fans, including a dear friend of mine, believe that the Return of the Jedi, makes for a fitting end-point for the Skywalker story, where a repented father and son save the galaxy by defeating the evil Emperor and thus bringing balance to the force. I can still see those celebratory fireworks and the statue of Emperor Palpatine tumbling down as a symbol of victory. That point inevitably leads me to one of my biggest complaint about The Last Jedi that Rian Johnson’s unintentionally dishonors Luke Skywalker’s legacy. 

“This is not going to go the way you think”, uttered from Luke’s lips to Rey in one of Ahch-Tou’s most dramatic scenes which now seems quite poignant. Luke was once a hero, and maybe he should have been left to revel in glory, but in The Last Jedi we now find him with his spirit broken, cut off to the force and isolated from those he loves, because of a massive misunderstanding between Luke and Ben Solo (aka Kylo Ren), that led Ben to rise against his former teacher and destroy Luke’s Jedi academy and a new generation of Jedi. Our perfect vision of Luke is also instantly shattered when he refuses to help Rey, the galaxy’s new hope, to reset that delicate balance between the light and the dark side of the force. But Rian Johnson’s unpredictability surprised me late in the film, changing my mind about my relationship with my original Star Wars hero, giving Luke closure, not quite the blazing lightsaber battle I hoped for, but nonetheless a solemn finale with Luke tormenting Kylo Ren through a telepathic force projection, before he faded away likened to Yoda’s exit in The Empire Strikes Back, while gazing out upon a twin sunset, reminiscent of that classic A New Hope scene on Tatooine.

Screen Shot 2017-12-25 at 10.01.30 PM.png

Johnson had always said that this trilogy wasn’t wholly Luke’s story, that it is Rey’s and that by making Luke a twisted and tormented former Jedi master dealing with failure and disappointment, it really in some respects helped set up the film’s effective ending and for us to truly now pin our hopes with Rey. I’ve come to accept that Luke’s death is probably as good as any finale for a beloved character (He may yet still return as a force ghost?) and sets up episode IX to allow characters like Kylo Ren, Rey, Poe and Finn to breathe and break free of the original trilogy’s shadow. “Let the past die,” Kylo Ren says. “Kill it, if you have to. That’s the only way to become who you were meant to be.” That said not everyone is happy with the ending. Some believe that it won’t be salvageable, especially since we are left with the presence of Leia, but no Carrie Fisher.

With the first anniversary of Carrie Fishers death nearly upon us, it is fitting that she has left us with an amazing and rich legacy as Star Wars first female heroine, especially in her last performance as an actress. Interestingly, I had only recently learnt how Fisher had a hand in rewriting most of her lines in this film. I can only imagine what she might have insisted on for episode IX, considering it is believed that she was going to play an integral part in it. 

The major strengths of the film I believe comes in many forms, especially its unpredictability. Take for example how no one saw Snoke’s demise coming or how Snoke’s ridicule of Kylo Ren further impaired his volatile state of mind. When Ren killed Snoke, we all hoped he would turn back to the light like his grandfather Anakin Skywalker did, but instead he chose by his own volition, to continue and not stray from his dangerous journey down the path towards the dark side. Adam Drivers guilt-ridden performance of Kylo Ren in my opinion steals the show, even ahead of what is believed to be Mark Hamill’s finest acting moment portraying Luke Skywalker. But lets not forget the strength of the film also lies in the four main female characters (Rey, Leia, Rose, and Holdo) getting things done and taking the fight to the First Order.

It annoys me a little that no matter what the makers of Star Wars do, hardcore fans will never be happy, especially with Disney’s emphasis on and inclusive nature to portray strong well-rounded female characters. A considerable backlash from fans comes from their horror that The Last Jedi is an all-conquering feminist movie. But my message to the kind of fan who originally shrugged off Rey, as a Mary Sue character after The Force Awakens, is that you need to put down their caveman club and embrace the momentous shift that society is advocating, that both men and women can co-exist, do the same things and work together side by side, even on-screen in a Star Wars movie.

Does it really matter that for a change, a female character like General Leia or her second in charge Vice Admiral Holdo (played by Laura Dern) can be strong, sceptical and dismissive of anything that their male counterpart might have to say? Some fan reactions are bewildering, especially in relation to how nice guy Poe Dameron (played by Oscar Isaac) was treated by Leia and Holdo. It’s almost as if women are not allowed to be opinionated strong leaders, especially when people like Poe are wrong. (Poe was put back into his place, notably for his subordination for ignoring direct orders from Leia, which ultimately cost the lives of many of their best fighter pilots, and later for questioning the authority of Holdo and her ability to make decisions and lead under pressure.) Anyway, I hope that we may remember in the years ahead how the brave, intelligent, and capable women of The Last Jedi saved the Resistance!

It is here I would like to pause and draw breathe and get back on topic about some more of The Last Jedi‘s strengths. That said I would briefly like to paraphrase what my good friend Sean Munger (See his review here) said to me a few days after he saw the film. He said that the major strength of the film was the chemistry between Daisy Ridley and Adam Driver. And that The Last Jedi story was not about epic space wars, but about a broken family. He went on to add that what a wonderful message Rey’s character send us. How a young woman, daughter of junk traders, can save the universe! Honestly, I couldn’t have said it better myself.

Cinematically, The Last Jedi may seem a little disjointed and unstructured with too many side stories, but here too lies its strength, as it is cleverly edited back and forth to keep up the suspense. These multiple plots I believe all eventually come together magically for the finale, set on a rich mineral planet of Crait. How gorgeous were those scenes of red and white during the climatic battle on the salt plains of Crait!!??!!

It is impossible to grasp everything that has changed my mind to truly embracing a film with such heart. Some of my favourite scenes involve Rey with Ren, and Luke with Leia, where director Rian Johnson has cleverly brought into focus another one of those mysteries of the force, where force sensitive characters can telepathically communicate with each other intimately across the galaxy. I loved the homage scene between Luke and R2D2 on board the Millennium Falcon, where R2D2 tries to emotionally blackmail Luke into joining the fight against the First Order. I also loved the moment where Leia is blown out of her ship’s bridge. We are momentarily left to fear that she is dead, until she wakes from her Jedi-like meditative state and reaches out with her hand to use the force to drag herself back into the ship. Finally we come to see Leia use her force sensitive abilities that Luke alludes to her having in the Return of the Jedi. Equally breathtaking is Vice Admiral Holdo’s ultimate sacrifices to save the Resistance, when she pilots the Resistance starship (the Raddus) into lightspeed right through the First Order destroyer. At the moment of impact, we expect to hear the roar of explosions, but instead the sound instantly drops out creating a surreal and striking visual of Snoke’s flagship breaking up. And finally, I loved the epic lightsaber duel in Snoke’s throne room between Rey and Ren against Snoke’s Elite Praetorian Guard.  

What I have said here is at least I hope a start to make amends to my initial reluctance to The Last Jedi. In regards to feeling underwhelmed by The Last Jedi, I never said I hated it, I initially thought that some things in it just didn’t work. The casino side story still doesn’t and a few other smaller flaws still annoy me, but overall on seeing it again I have come to appreciate how Rian Johnson wanted to challenge and provoke us and or maybe even shake up our long standing dogmatic view of Star Wars.  (Maybe in hindsight I should have tempered my expectations of it in the first place?) In short, it is an entertaining film, probably like no other Star Wars film before it, and arguably fitting where we find ourselves and our love and desire to see this saga move on from the past. And I think that it is also fair to say that the faith Disney that has shown in writer-director Rian Johnson is justified. Where to from here? I don’t know. Close your eyes, breathe and imagine the possibilities!

Rating: 8/10

Photo Credits: The film stills from The Last Jedi used in this article are courtesy and copyright material of Disney/Lucasfilm. I make use of the images under the rational of fair use, to enable me to makes an important contribution to the reader’s understanding of the article, which could not practically be communicated by words alone. In fact, I hope that this review helps to promote the anticipation and excitement of the film.

15 comments on “Star Wars: The Last Jedi in-depth fan review: ‘From being underwhelmed to truly embracing a film with heart.’

  1. Great review! You make some terrific points. And thanks for the shout-out.

  2. If you have moved more towards embracing the film with successive viewings, that indicates strengths, doesn’t it? I’m glad.

    Many of your points I agree with, some I don’ quite see it the same way. While I love the strength of Leia and Rey, I found the ‘flyboy’ putdowns of Poe patronising – a kind of reverse 60s sexism. Better no sexism at all, I reckon.

    Totally agree about the casino section – what a waste of time. Next viewing, I’ll take a toilet break during that scene. By the way, I thought I saw one of those animal tending children use the force to grab his broom at the end of the film, kind of an ‘Accio Broom’ moment – did you see that or were my eyes playing tricks after 4 ¼ hours our whatever it was?

    Can I end with a genuine question? Did you believe Kylo’s laying out of Rey’s parentage? I just assumed it was bollocks, but maybe that’s because I so want her to be his brother.
    The Skywalker saga continues…

    • I guess I kind of deliberately didn’t touch on Rey’s parentage in my review because it doesn’t really matter to me. Obviously to Rey it is very important because she wants to know her place in the galaxy and why she was supposedly abandoned. But whether she is important, or a nobody, as Kylo Ren explicitly points out, it makes for good drama, right?  My gut tells me that I think he is lying. Though Kylo seems to really believe it? That said, Rey as a nobody goes a long way to help Star Wars move forward. “Let the past die, kill it if you have to”, just might be the most profound words spoken by a Star Wars character, especially in light of the proposed new triology planned by Rian Johnson.

  3. Interesting how after being underwhelmed th 1st time, u can still go back for a 2nd viewing
    Here is my Review:
    Happy New Year!

    • The amazing thing about Star Wars is that we are always going to debate what we love and hate about it. My intension was always to see it a second time. And talking about time, it has a funny way of allowing us to readdress how we feel about each instalment, especially in the context of when they were made and why. The Last Jedi may feel, for example, feminist in outlook now, but in five, ten or even twenty years time we won’t even bat an eye lid over its controversy. 

      In regards to feeling underwhelmed by The Last Jedi, I just want to reiterate that I never said I hated it (and I’m not insinuating you said that), I initially thought that some things in it just didn’t work. Happy New Year my friend!

      • I do not hate Th Last Jedi – there are so many fans who admit they do.
        Without a discernible plot, or characterisation, this is no more than a 150 minute Disney commercial – I simply want nothing more to do with it.
        If u find anything in this worthy of appreciation, be my guest!
        And a Happy New Year to u, Robert!

  4. The Burning Blogger Of Bedlam

    Great to finally read your review – I was waiting for it for days 🙂
    I’m glad you’ve found your peace with this film; and you argue it out very well in this piece. For me, this is is basically a bad film with some very good moments in it. But I entirely acknowledge that my view of this film is subject to time and reflection – and that I may feel very differently about it a year from now.
    On one point, I have to disagree with you and maintain my position – the social-messaging aspect of this film was a massive problem. It’s not that the message itself is wrong or bad – it;s that it has no subtlety, but is presented like a sledge-hammer, deliberately designed to draw maximum attention. The effect is that it interrupts and burdens the film, making it feel more like a sociology class than a real story.
    But I don’t entirely hate this film – I think it has good things in it, as you have highlighted in this review. My present feeling is that this might be the point where I part ways with the franchise, going forward: but I know, really, I have to give it a lot more time yet to see what I really feel in the long-term.
    One last point though. I was discussing this with someone yesterday, and we came to the conclusion that all of us – as Star Wars fans, collectively – are in different stages of the common ‘grief’ process; and that this disparity of where we each are in the stages is why there’s such a difference in everyone’s reviews. So, some of us are in the Denial Stage, some of us are in the Bargaining Stage, some of us are in the Acceptance Stage, etc. At a guess, I would say you are in either the Bargaining Stage or the Acceptance Stage.
    I myself was seriously contemplating erasing everything after ROTJ/ROTS from my personal ‘head canon’ and living in a Star Wars bubble – which, admittedly, is a little dramatic: and puts me probably firmly in the Denial Stage still. 🙂

    • I read somewhere that the hilt of Luke Skywalker’s lightsaber cleaved in two – represents how we are all feeling about The Last Jedi at the moment. And yes, I would say I sit comfortable somewhere between the Bargaining and Acceptance stage. I know you, well enough as a fan, that you might in time come around to it. The bigger picture might look different for you, only after seeing the final instalment.

      • The Burning Blogger Of Bedlam

        Perhaps. I’ve decided not to watch it again for at least six months. I need that long to calm down. I watched both Empire and Sith over X-Mas and felt comfortable again – because I felt all my Star Wars love re-asserting itself.

  5. I’ve been a hardcore Star Wars fan my whole life and the thought of not loving it anymore is very troublesome. I think a lot of us are dealing with that possibility after the Last Jedi, and so we look for things to love about it. I was an apologist for much of the prequel era but felt vindicated when that era produced The Clone Wars TV series. Back on track.
    I really feel that the Last Jedi blew it as far as continuity with the force awakens and character development. Except for maybe Kylo Ren and Rey’s developing connection, we still don’t know much about the other main characters and they don’t know much about each other! This was a dull movie for the most part, and the worst part about it was the horrible treatment of Luke Skywalker. Mark Hamill was right, that’s not the Luke that we knew. And the reasoning for him to become so depressed he wants to go and die alone was ridiculous. I’m sorry, it just doesn’t add up.
    For the first time in my life, I’m not excited about the next installment of this Saga. There’s no Cliffhanger at the end of The Last Jedi, no one has been fundamentally changed, not even by the death of the sagas hero. I just don’t get it. I hope episode 9 can redeem this mess somehow, but I don’t know if it’s possible. If you’re a hardcore Star Wars fan and you like this movie, I envy you! Maybe I’ll come around eventually, but I don’t see it happening. Here’s hoping someone makes a really good Star Wars movie eventually.

  6. Pingback: Han shoots first! Solo: A Star Wars Story fan review. – Rearview Mirror

  7. Once again, great post and those are all perfectly valid points you made about the movie. Just like you I felt baffled and confused after my first viewing of the film. My expectations were so grand and when the movie didn’t live up to those expectations I felt betrayed. I despised nearly everything about ‘The Last Jedi’ (except every scene with Kylo Ren who is easily my favorite character in the movie.) But then after seeing it for the second time, it was like my mind had been freed and I could enjoy the film for what it truly is; a story about light and dark and the evolution of the franchise.

    Yes, Luke may not be the knight in shining armor that we expected but in retrospect that makes sense. He failed his nephew and would cause a lot of suffering via Kylo Ren. For him, it was noble to hide away from the rest of the galaxy so that he would not cause any more pain.

    The relationship between Kylo Ren and Rey was beautifully written and acted. It was a brilliant turn of events that I did not expect and will go down as one of the most interesting relationships in the franchise.

    I loved Rose for her fierce duty to protect goodness and those that she loves. Her relationship with Finn is one of the highlights of the film for me and I hope to see more with them together in ‘Episode IX’. (The Canto Bight scenes can be a bit taxing to watch though.)

    And I absolutely LOVED the duel in Snoke’s throne room. It was a choreography masterpiece. And what makes it better is that the real actors acted that fight scene out which makes it all the more epic. Hands down best lightsaber duel in the franchise.

    I loved this review. 🙂

    • Thank you so much Annlyel. Our passion for Star Wars can sometimes cloud our judgement. Despite the controversy, it is a very good film, even more so on the eve of its first anniversary.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: